| Columbus Crew - 1996 |
| Total | 62 |
|---|---|
| Brian McBride | 19 |
| Pete Marino | 11 |
| Adrian Paz | 7 |
| Brian Maisonneuve | 5 |
| Marcelo Carrera | 4 |
| Paul Caligiuri | 3 |
| Doctor Khumalo | 3 |
| Billy Thompson | 2 |
| Robert Warzycha | 2 |
| Brian Bliss | 1 |
| Mike Clark | 1 |
| Ricardo Iribarren | 1 |
| Todd Yeagley | 1 |
| Own Goals | 2 |