| Columbus Crew - 2012 |
| Total | 44 |
|---|---|
| Jairo Arrieta | 9 |
| Eddie Gaven | 9 |
| Federico Higuain | 5 |
| Justin Meram | 4 |
| Milovan Mirosevic | 4 |
| Emilio Renteria | 3 |
| Chad Marshall | 2 |
| Tony Tchani | 2 |
| Bernardo Anor | 1 |
| Chris Birchall | 1 |
| Cole Grossman | 1 |
| Sebastian Miranda | 1 |
| Olman Vargas | 1 |
| Josh Williams | 1 |