| New York - 2019 |
| Total | 56 |
|---|---|
| Daniel Royer | 11 |
| Brian White | 9 |
| Alejandro Romero Gamarra | 5 |
| Tom Barlow | 4 |
| Christian Casseres Jr. | 3 |
| Alex Muyl | 3 |
| Omir Fernandez | 2 |
| Aaron Long | 2 |
| Marc Rzatkowski | 2 |
| Bradley Wright-Phillips | 2 |
| Kyle Duncan | 1 |
| Derrick Etienne Jr. | 1 |
| Andreas Ivan | 1 |
| Connor Lade | 1 |
| Kemar Lawrence | 1 |
| Michael Amir Murillo | 1 |
| Sean Nealis | 1 |
| Tim Parker | 1 |
| Josh Sims | 1 |
| Amro Tarek | 1 |
| Own Goals | 3 |