| New York City - 2016 |
| Total | 62 |
|---|---|
| David Villa | 23 |
| Frank Lampard | 12 |
| Thomas McNamara | 5 |
| Steven Mendoza | 5 |
| Jack Harrison | 4 |
| Khiry Shelton | 4 |
| Tony Taylor | 2 |
| RJ Allen | 1 |
| Frederic Brillant | 1 |
| Mix Diskerud | 1 |
| Ronald Matarrita | 1 |
| Jefferson Mena | 1 |
| Andrea Pirlo | 1 |
| Kwadwo Poku | 1 |